A switch between SEO plugins is complete when the required values remain in the site's public HTML. The message “Import complete” confirms that the operation ran, but does not by itself prove that a product page kept its manual title, a noindex archive stayed noindex, or an old address leads to the new page.
Below is a workflow for switching from Yoast SEO to Rank Math on WordPress. Screen names follow the developers' current documentation; translations may differ in the Russian localization. If you only need a different text score in the editor, first decide whether that justifies migrating the other settings.
A title is a page heading, and a description is its description for search engines. A canonical indicates the preferred primary URL, while robots contains indexing rules; noindex means the page must not be included in the search index.
What to record before switching plugins
Make a checklist of URLs representing different site rules: the home page, a service page, an article with a manual description, a product, a category archive, and a tag archive with noindex. Add a page with a deliberately chosen canonical and an old URL that redirects to a new service page. This sample helps reveal the different effects of a single operation.
For each URL, save the title, description, canonical, and robots value from the original HTML, along with the expected behavior. Note the source beside each value: an individual Yoast field, a post type template, or an archive setting. A screenshot of the editor is useful, but the HTML is what shows the result for visitors and search engine crawlers.
Separately, list the active redirects and how they are stored. They may belong to Yoast Premium, another plugin, the web server, or the hosting provider. Do not assume that all redirects are Yoast data just because Yoast is installed. Record the versions of WordPress and both plugins so the developer can reproduce the checks.
Example: three different rules
Imagine a small workshop website. This is an illustrative example, not a client story. The title “Range hood repair in the workshop — time and cost” has been set manually on the page /services/repair/. The description for the article /blog/noise/ has also been written manually. The archive /tag/draft-notes/ must have noindex, although its published articles are allowed to appear in search results.
After the import, the first page got the generic title “Repair — site name,” and the archive lost its noindex. The home page still looks as expected. If you check only that page, you could mistakenly conclude that the migration worked. Two rows in the checklist will immediately reveal the discrepancies: the individual text was lost, and the archive rule changed.
Another row concerns /old-repair/: the old address must redirect to /services/repair/, and the new page must open without another redirect. Check this separately from the metadata. A correct title does not confirm that the redirect route is intact.
How to prepare a copy and a rollback option
Back up the database and files, then restore them to a test URL. Confirm that this copy opens and that emails, orders, and integrations do not affect the live store. Test plugin changes where an error will not alter published pages.
Save the original settings and checklist values before starting the import. An export of one plugin's settings is not necessarily suitable for another: the dedicated import from Yoast and uploading a Rank Math settings file are different operations. Do not treat them as interchangeable just because their button names are similar.
Define the rollback procedure in advance: restore the previous database and active plugin set, clear only the applicable caches, and recheck the test URLs. Simply reactivating Yoast does not prove that all changes have been rolled back. If a contractor proposes a rollback without a database, ask them to show which data will remain and how they have verified it.
Where to run the Yoast import in Rank Math
Rank Math's official guide describes importing through the setup wizard and through the Status & Tools screen. One practical option for testing is to open Rank Math SEO → Status & Tools → Import & Export, find Other Plugins, select Yoast SEO data, and run Import. If the Import & Export tab is missing, enable Advanced Mode, Rank Math's advanced mode. Record the selected data categories and the operation's result.
The setup wizard also has an import step. There is no need to use both methods in a row for reliability: choose one and check the result. During the switch, leave only one active SEO plugin responsible for the public tags. You can deactivate Yoast during testing while keeping its data for a rollback.
If the data remains in the editor after the switch but is not output on the page, check how SEO tags are connected in a WordPress theme.
After importing, open the same posts in the editor and compare their individual fields. Then check the public HTML. If a field is populated but the HTML is different, look for a template rule, another source of tags, or a cache. If the value is already missing from the editor, investigate the import of that specific field rather than Google's results.
What to check separately for redirects
Rank Math describes importing redirects from Yoast Premium. This is a separate set of data. If redirects were stored on the server, switching SEO plugins does not transfer them automatically or remove the need to check them.
For each old URL on the checklist, record the first response code and the final URL. Check the destination page: it should show the intended product or service, have accessible content, and not redirect again. Redirecting to the home page instead of the previous service page is different behavior, even if the browser successfully loads the site.
Do not include bulk CSV redirect import in the promised result without checking the Rank Math edition: its documentation says this feature is available in PRO. If the site uses a different redirect tool, the contractor's task is to preserve the existing mechanism, not replace it without need.
When to move from the copy to the live site
Record the settings that passed testing on the copy and the procedure for applying them. If an editor changes the manual description on the live site after the test, the old copy no longer contains the current text. Check for such changes before migration. After applying the changes on the live domain, recheck the test URLs: different caches and server rules may produce a different response, even with the same database.
How to accept the migration and find unchecked areas
Give the developer the checklist along with the specific expected results: “Keep the manual title on the service page, leave the tag archive with noindex, and redirect the old URL to the new service page.” Ask them to provide before-and-after evidence: HTML values, response codes, and details of which plugin now outputs the tags.
Acceptance includes repeating the checks in a regular browser window while logged out of WordPress. Make sure the rules are the same for visitors and administrators after clearing the cache. If the store has several product types or languages, add the relevant pages: one successful service page does not cover the entire catalog.
A page's absence from search results immediately after migration does not explain the cause of a problem. First establish whether the settings and public response match. Indexing data is checked separately and may reflect an earlier crawl. For the sitemap, see the guide to WordPress sitemaps and Yoast; to check published URLs, see the technical site audit. The result of the migration should be a preserved set of rules verified against examples, not just a new plugin icon in the menu.